On This Day in Politics: June 26, 2015
On June 26, 2015, the United States Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., ruled that states must permit same-sex couples to marry and recognize their lawful marriages from other states. The decision in Obergefell v. Hodges resolved challenges from Michigan, Kentucky, Ohio and Tennessee. Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote for a five-justice majority, joined by Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan. The ruling rested on the Fourteenth Amendment's guarantees of liberty and equal protection. It established a nationwide constitutional rule for civil marriage, replacing a system in which a couple's legal recognition could depend on the state involved.
The litigation concerned practical family relationships as well as constitutional principles. The petitioners included couples seeking marriage licenses and people seeking recognition of marriages already performed elsewhere. Jim Obergefell's challenge concerned Ohio's refusal to recognize his marriage to John Arthur on Arthur's death certificate. Federal district courts had ruled for the challengers, but the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed those decisions. That disagreement brought the cases before the Supreme Court. The question was therefore both whether a state could exclude same-sex couples from marriage and whether it could refuse to recognize an existing lawful marriage.
Kennedy's opinion treated the freedom to marry as a fundamental right and explained why same-sex couples could not be excluded from it. The majority connected individual choice, intimate association, family security and marriage's place in public life. It also considered the relationship between due process and equal protection, rather than treating those constitutional guarantees as unrelated arguments. The dissenting justices disputed the majority's interpretation and the judiciary's authority to settle the issue. Their objections made clear that the decision involved a profound disagreement about constitutional reasoning and democratic institutions, even as the majority's judgment supplied the governing rule.
The immediate consequence was a national requirement for state licensing and recognition. President Barack Obama welcomed the decision that morning and emphasized the uncertainty created when marriage recognition changed across state borders. Yet the judgment did not resolve every question involving sexuality, religion or discrimination in public life. It addressed civil marriage and acknowledged the protection of religious advocacy and teaching. Its longer significance lies in the relationship it established between a familiar legal institution and equal constitutional citizenship. The anniversary marks a specific judicial decision with direct effects on families, while the broader history includes years of organizing, litigation, legislation and changing public attitudes. Families felt its consequences immediately.
The consolidated cases came from four states within the Sixth Circuit. They placed marriage licensing and recognition of marriages performed elsewhere before the Court together.
The petitioners' circumstances included parenting, illness and bereavement. Those concrete consequences helped explain why the dispute involved more than the wording on a marriage license.
The majority required states to make civil marriage available to same-sex couples. States also had to recognize qualifying marriages lawfully performed in other states.
The decision concerned government recognition of marriage. It did not supply a complete answer to every future dispute about religious liberty or discrimination in other settings.
The ruling connected the fundamental right to marry with the Fourteenth Amendment's protections. It became a central reference point in debates about liberty, equality and judicial interpretation.
June 26 records the Court's judgment. The advocacy, state-level decisions and earlier litigation that made the case possible belong to the longer history surrounding that day.
Explore more of "On This Day ..."
Discover more events from the same date across news, politics, technology, sports, and other fields. Each link highlights significant moments that shaped history on different fronts.
