On This Day in Politics: November 5, 1872
On November 5, 1872, Susan B. Anthony cast a ballot in the presidential election in Rochester, New York, despite laws that excluded women from voting there. She and other women had registered before election day, arguing that the Fourteenth Amendment's protections of citizenship supported their right to vote. Election inspectors accepted her ballot, creating a direct test of that argument. The act did not establish legal voting rights for women in New York. Instead, it brought the conflict between citizenship and electoral exclusion into a federal criminal case that would draw attention to the suffrage campaign.
Anthony's action grew from a wider strategy among women's rights activists after the Civil War. The Fourteenth Amendment defined national citizenship and prohibited states from abridging citizens' privileges or immunities. Some campaigners contended that women, as citizens, already possessed the right to vote and should attempt to exercise it. Virginia and Francis Minor helped develop this argument, which encouraged challenges to registration rules in different communities. Anthony pursued it in Rochester with other women, including her sisters. Their registration and voting attempts were deliberate political interventions. They sought to make officials and courts confront a restriction that ordinary electoral practice treated as an accepted condition of citizenship.
The immediate acceptance of Anthony's ballot did not protect her from prosecution. She was arrested later in November, and the inspectors who had permitted her to register and vote also faced legal consequences. In June 1873, her trial took place in Canandaigua, New York, before Justice Ward Hunt. He rejected the constitutional defense and directed a guilty verdict rather than allowing the jury to reach its own decision. Anthony was sentenced to a fine of one hundred dollars and court costs, which she refused to pay. Those proceedings occurred months after the election; they should not be collapsed into the November 5 event. Her vote had initiated the confrontation, while the subsequent trial exposed the legal response.
The broader constitutional strategy also met a setback when the Supreme Court ruled in the separate case of Minor v. Happersett in 1875 that citizenship did not itself confer voting rights. Campaigners continued to pursue changes through state measures and a federal constitutional amendment. The Nineteenth Amendment was ratified in 1920, after Anthony's death, prohibiting denial of the vote on account of sex. Even that change did not remove every barrier faced by women, particularly those excluded through discriminatory voting practices. Anthony was not the first woman ever to cast an American ballot. Her 1872 vote is remembered because it turned a routine electoral act into a purposeful, nationally significant challenge to the political exclusion of women.
The Fourteenth Amendment argument treated voting as a right already belonging to citizens. This differed from asking lawmakers to grant a wholly new privilege.
The registration inspectors accepted Anthony's claim before the election. Their later prosecution shows that the dispute also concerned the officials who administered access to the ballot.
Voting occurred on November 5; arrest and trial followed. The anniversary should not be illustrated or described as though all three events happened on the same day.
Justice Ward Hunt directed the verdict at the 1873 trial. The resulting fine and Anthony's refusal to pay became part of the suffrage movement's public account of the case.
Minor v. Happersett was a separate case involving another woman's registration challenge. Its 1875 outcome rejected the claim that citizenship alone guaranteed suffrage.
The Nineteenth Amendment addressed exclusion on account of sex. Racial discrimination and other obstacles meant that the formal constitutional change did not create equal practical access for every woman.
Explore more of "On This Day ..."
Discover more events from the same date across news, politics, technology, sports, and other fields. Each link highlights significant moments that shaped history on different fronts.
