Susan B. Anthony, 1873

Realistic editorial recreation of Susan B. Anthony, 1873, in period-appropriate clothing in a quiet study.

“The only question left to be settled, now, is: Are women persons?”

Susan B. Anthony asked this question in her argument on women’s right to vote, printed with the account of her 1873 trial. She had voted in Rochester, New York, in the presidential election of 1872 and was prosecuted for doing so. Her speech used the language of the Constitution to challenge the exclusion of women from political participation. Immediately before this rhetorical question, she moved from recognition as a person to recognition as a citizen, then argued that citizenship carried rights a state could not abridge. The question is deliberately startling because the humanity of women should not require proof. Its purpose was to expose a conflict between inclusive constitutional language and an electoral system that excluded women. Anthony was advancing a contested interpretation of that language, not reporting that courts had already accepted her conclusion. The distinction is necessary to understanding the political force and the historical outcome of her argument.

The sentence makes exclusion appear as a problem that demands justification rather than as a custom entitled to continue without explanation. If a political system claims to speak for the people, its treatment of the people it prevents from voting becomes central to its legitimacy. Anthony pressed this issue through legal reasoning and public advocacy. Her prosecution also shows why the wording of a principle and its effective enforcement must be considered separately. She was convicted and fined; her claim did not secure a judicial victory establishing nationwide women’s suffrage. It would therefore be misleading to present the quotation as a simple statement of the law at that moment. It was an effort to change the understanding and application of constitutional rights. The force of the question lies in its challenge to a boundary that political authorities treated as ordinary. Calling that boundary ordinary could not answer whether it was defensible.

For readers today, the quotation offers a way to investigate the categories through which participation is granted or withheld. Who is included when a government describes its citizens? What reason is given for an exclusion, and does that reason withstand the principles the government itself professes? Historical precision also requires recognizing that suffrage movements contained disagreements and exclusions of their own. Respect for Anthony’s argument does not require treating every position she took, or every tactic used by the movement, as beyond criticism. A quotation can illuminate one argument while leaving room for a fuller assessment of its speaker. The enduring political issue is the distance between formal membership and meaningful participation. Being governed, paying taxes, or being subject to punishment does not by itself provide a voice in the decisions that shape those obligations. Anthony’s question calls attention to that unequal arrangement and asks its defenders to explain it. The January 29 placement is part of this daily series, not the date of her trial or the election in which she voted.

Anthony voted in Rochester in November 1872 and was tried in 1873. The speech is printed in the published account of the proceedings.

The quoted question follows her use of constitutional language about persons, citizenship, and privileges or immunities.

She argued that women's exclusion from voting conflicted with the rights attached to citizenship.

That was her contested constitutional argument. Her conviction shows that it was not accepted as a judicial victory in her case.

The question helps distinguish formal recognition as a member of society from a meaningful voice in its government.

Studying this argument also leaves room to examine the broader movement's disagreements and its treatment of other excluded groups.

Explore more "Quotes of The Day"

Discover more notable quotes from influential voices across politics, science, business, technology, sports, and culture. Each quote offers insight into how ideas, beliefs, and decisions shape the world around us.