“Progress is possible and innocuous only when it is subject to the control of reason.”
Andrei Sakharov wrote this sentence in his 1975 Nobel lecture, read by his wife, Elena Bonner, on December 11 because he was not permitted to attend. The wording comes from the published English translation. In the lecture, the Soviet physicist and dissident considered the benefits and dangers of scientific and technological development. He rejected the idea that society could solve its difficulties simply by stopping progress. At the same time, he argued that progress needed intellectual freedom and informed judgment. The quotation expresses that connection: human capability should grow alongside the capacity to examine its purposes, consequences, and possible abuses.
The word reason asks for more than confidence that a new development will prove useful. It requires an explanation of how a claim can be examined and what would count as evidence against it. In politics, decisions about technology can affect people who did not choose the risks they face. Their concerns deserve a hearing alongside the promises offered by officials or experts. A reasoned decision can acknowledge uncertainty without treating every outcome as equally likely. It can also distinguish a supported objection from a convenient assertion. The value of scrutiny lies in improving judgment, including judgment about when action is justified and when an approach needs correction.
The surrounding passage placed particular importance on an informed public, freedom of conscience, education, and access to information. It criticized the intellectual constraints of the Soviet system and connected open discussion with environmental problems and the military uses of scientific knowledge. These details clarify what control means in the sentence. It should not be reduced to an unchecked bureaucracy deciding which questions people may ask. Sakharov treated openness as a condition for responsible progress. A system that suppresses unwelcome findings may appear orderly while losing the ability to recognize its own failures. Intellectual freedom helps people test assurances that might otherwise depend only on authority.
The quotation remains useful wherever a public institution promises improvement through a powerful new capability. Readers can ask who can inspect the evidence, how dissenting arguments are considered, and what means exist to challenge harmful results. These questions do not require rejecting development or assuming that every innovation conceals a threat. They require institutions capable of learning in public. An honest account of progress includes its limits, the people exposed to its consequences, and the possibility that a course will need to change. Sakharov’s sentence invites a demanding form of confidence: confidence supported by inquiry, open to criticism, and answerable to the lives affected by the choices made in its name.
The sentence appears in the published English translation of Sakharov’s 1975 Nobel lecture. Elena Bonner read the lecture on December 11.
Sakharov was not permitted to attend. His argument supported progress while insisting on informed examination of its consequences.
Reason requires evidence that can be questioned. Confidence in a promised benefit should not exclude scrutiny of risks or possible abuses.
The surrounding passage emphasized intellectual freedom, education, and access to information. It challenged restrictions on open inquiry.
Control should not be confused with suppressing unwelcome findings. An institution needs ways to recognize and correct its failures.
Readers can ask how evidence is examined and who may challenge a decision. Responsible progress stays open to criticism and revision.
Explore more "Quotes of The Day"
Discover more notable quotes from influential voices across politics, science, business, technology, sports, and culture. Each quote offers insight into how ideas, beliefs, and decisions shape the world around us.
